First Mothers Lays Formal Genocide Charges Against Irish State

By -
By Kathy McMahon 
​
4th April, 2017 - Following correspondence to our group from the Irish Attorney General, Irish First Mothers has today ​replied to the AG laying ​​formal charges of genocide against the Irish State on behalf of around 70 mothers formerly resident in Mother and Baby homes.

We have also written requesting the Presidency of the International Criminal Court (ICC) to engage with Ireland on this issue, on an informal and voluntary basis.

Our claim under Ireland's International  Criminal Court Act of 2006, alleges crimes of genocide and failure to prevent genocide by the Irish State in respect of its historical treatment of unmarried mothers. Specifically we assert that our sequestration in State-sanctioned religious homes and the subsequent coercive adoption of our children violated two signature genocide criteria enshrined in Irish law: grievous mental harm and forced transfer of children.

In support of our claim to the Attorney General,  we cited public comments by former judge of the Irish Supreme Court, Catherine McGuinness about the historical defect of real choice afforded to mothers to keep their infants. Judge McGuinness had commented from her direct experience as a former member of the official Irish Adoption Board: "they really hadn't a great deal of choice....  they were, shall we say, 'encouraged' to place their children for adoption". [Ray Darcy Show Audio]

Compounding a structural denial of choice, we assert that mothers suffering diminished capacity to consent as a result of incarceration and infant loss trauma, were dragooned regardless into signing away their parental rights under systematically coercive adoption procedures.

Our genocide claim also cited public comments by former Irish Minister for Justice, Paddy Cooney who addressed the seminal Irish Adoption Workers Conference, saying: "I think that we are all agreed that the consensus opinion in our society is to the effect that adoption is better for the illegitimate baby than to be cared for by its mother".

We assert that Mr. Cooney's comments in the setting of the first State adoption conference in 1974 indicates State bias to dispense with our consent in pursuit of fundamentally genocidal aims. In the eyes of genocidal perpetrators, we were an outcast sect of Christianity, dubbed "fallen women" and undeserving of human rights.

We demanded that the Attorney General now affords our claim its due process of justice under domestic genocide law. It is our position that our genocide claim is simply a legally novel perspective on a body of already well-established facts. The systemic structure of these practices are already matters of public and academic record or subject of prior State legal inquiry reports.

Therefore, we seek that the State should forthwith admit prosecution of itself -and only contest its guilt in regard conspiracy to commit genocide in collaboration with Irish religious institutions. We ask also for prosecution of other bodies; of departments of government; and of sundry individuals who were key architects of these genocidal policies. Determining whom to prosecute would be a matter for the judgement of the Prosecutor.

In Irish law, genocide is not subject to being statute-barred by reason of elapsed time since the alleged crimes. Nevertheless our case is confined to mothers only because our genocide claim derives from the perpetrators definitively religious characterization of our motherhood. At this time we have not communicated with the Irish Director of Public Prosecutions office, because we are affording the State time to consider these novel legal matters. 


​We will not ask the ICC to prosecute these issues. We seek only a domestic prosecutor. However we have urged the Irish Attorney General and the President of the International Criminal Court, Judge Silvia Fernández de Gurmendi to use the established ICC conduits of informal consultation to ensure that Ireland now follows best practice. We maintain that international genocide laws would be brought into disrepute if the Irish State fails to apply the same rigour in dealing with domestic allegations, as it would impose on external State parties to international genocide agreements.

Irish First mothers has in recent years been invited to consult in regard to these issues with two Ministers of Government; testified on invitation to a committee of the Irish parliament and on invitation to the Investigation Committee of the Commission of Investigation into Mother and Baby Homes.

CONTACTS
Attorney General: +353 1 631 4000 or info@ag.irlgov.ie
UN Committee On Human Rights +41 22 917 9220 or InfoDesk@ohchr.org
CoE Commissioner for Human Rights +33 3 88 41 34 21 or commissioner@coe.int

 DOCUMENTS
“...in the case of "domestic" genocides, these are generally committed by or with the complicity of Governments, with the bizarre consequence that the Governments would be required to prosecute themselves.”
Genocide as Social Practice re UN Whitaker Report on Genocide

“National authorities bear the primary responsibility, in the first instance, to investigate and prosecute those most responsible for the commission of mass crimes.”


REPORTS
Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights Report 2017 http://bit.ly/2ouuQFS
UN Committee On Human Rights Report 2014 http://bit.ly/2oRPL1K
Irish Human Rights Commission M&B Homes Report 2014 http://bit.ly/2nPJ011
Irish State Covered-Up 2012 Tuam Baby Deaths Report http://bit.ly/2nPLlJb


NEWS ARTICLES

Comments

  1. Independent Regional Mothers3 April 2017 at 22:08

    Well done I am so proud of my dear Irish friends - sending you all the positive energy and Independent Regional Mothers (mayor Australian stakeholder for mothers) stand at your side all the way - loving hugs to you all

    ReplyDelete
  2. Kathy Mcahon4 April 2017 at 12:35

    Thank you Brenda.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

I was Ann Lovett's Boyfrined

By -
Image
I was Ann Lovett’s boyfriend Ann Lovett died aged 15 in 1984 after giving birth at a grotto in Granard, Co Longford – a tragedy that continues to resonate. Today, Ann’s former boyfriend Ricky McDonnell speaks publicly for the first time 5th May, 2018 Rosita Boland 20 Images Video Richard “Ricky” McDonnell: “At the beginning I was silent out of fear, and then it was out of respect.” Photograph: Brenda Fitzsimons/The Irish Times Richard “Ricky” McDonnell is standing at the gate, staring at a house on Colmcille Terrace, Granard, Co Longford. There was a time, 34 years ago, when he knew this house inside out. It was here he had lived from the age of six to 17 – including several years on his own – until he had to leave. It was here he had spent many hours with his former girlfriend Ann Lovett, who died aged 15 after giving birth at the grotto in the town on January 31st, 1984. It was here, on that January day, Ricky McDonnell’s life changed u...
Read more

Memorial Celebrating Mother And Child Bond Unveiled In Victoria

By -
Image
Front: Brenda Coughlan , Spokesperson for Independent Regional Mothers. Rear: Former Deputy Premier of Victoria, Peter Ryan ; Former Premier of Victoria, Ted Ballieu ; Hon. Darren Chester , a Commonwealth Minister representing Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull. In Victoria Park , Sale, Victoria, Australia . 17th March VICTORIA - Leading Victoria lawmakers gathered in Sale, Victoria today to celebrate with mother's rights campaigner Brenda Coughlan, at the Victoria Park unveiling of a statue honoring the special bond between mother and child. Former Premier of Victoria, Ted Ballieu and Former Deputy Premier of Victoria, Peter Ryan attended as  Hon. Darren Chester, a Commonwealth Minister representing Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull and  Ms. Coughlan, a spokesperson for Independent Regional Mothers , jointly unveiled the statue by Andrew Poppleton entitled "Mother and Child – Cherished". The event follows on from national and state leve...
Read more